According to the IRS, more than 3 million eligible taxpayers failed to claim the Premium Tax Credit in a recent filing year — leaving an estimated $2 billion in refundable credits uncollected. Most of those people were not wealthy. They were working people who simply did not know the credit existed, or assumed they didn’t qualify.
Rochelle Mendez is one of those people. Or she was, until this past March.
I met Rochelle on a Tuesday afternoon at a United Way-sponsored free tax preparation clinic operating out of a community center in East Knoxville. She was sitting at a folding table across from a certified IRS VITA volunteer, a printout of her W-2s and marketplace insurance statements spread between them. She had arrived expecting a routine filing. What she got was something closer to a reckoning.
Three Decades Behind the Wheel, and No Safety Net in Sight
Rochelle Mendez is 54 years old and has been driving commercial trucks for 26 years. She works for a regional carrier based in Knoxville — long hauls, mostly Southeast routes, sometimes extending into Ohio and Texas. She and her husband, Dennis, have been married for 35 years. Their two adult children are out of the house now, and Dennis retired last year from his job at a distribution warehouse, bringing in a modest pension of roughly $880 a month.
When I asked Rochelle to describe her financial situation plainly, she did not hesitate. “We’re not broke, but we’re not comfortable either,” she told me. “Dennis worked 30 years for that pension and it’s not enough to live on. I’m still driving because I have to be.”
Her trucking employer does not offer health insurance. That has been the case for most of her career. For years, she went without coverage entirely — a gamble she knew was dangerous but felt she had no choice about. In 2023, after a close call involving a minor cardiac event (“They called it a stress episode, but it scared me straight,” she said), she finally enrolled in a marketplace plan through HealthCare.gov.
She chose a Silver plan with a monthly premium of $847. She paid that full amount every month throughout 2024 and 2025, budgeting carefully to make it work. What she did not know — what nobody had told her — was that she likely qualified for the Premium Tax Credit, which could have dramatically reduced that monthly cost.
What the Tax Clinic Volunteer Found in Her Return
The VITA volunteer working Rochelle’s file — a retired accountant named Gary who volunteers at the clinic every filing season — ran her household income figures and almost immediately flagged the issue. Rochelle and Dennis filed jointly. Her trucking wages came to approximately $53,400 for 2025. Dennis’s pension added another $8,000. Their combined adjusted gross income landed at roughly $61,400.
At that income level for a two-person household, Rochelle fell squarely within the eligibility range for the Premium Tax Credit. The credit is calculated based on household income as a percentage of the Federal Poverty Level, and at roughly 390% of the FPL for a two-person household in Tennessee, she qualified for meaningful assistance. Gary estimated her credit at $3,100 — money she could receive as a refund because she had paid the full premiums herself rather than claiming advance payments during the year.
The moment Gary showed her the Form 8962 calculation, Rochelle’s demeanor shifted visibly. She had walked in analytical and composed — she described herself to me as someone who “reads the fine print on everything” — but this caught her completely off guard. She had assumed that because she earned a steady paycheck, she wouldn’t qualify for any government credits. That assumption had cost her thousands of dollars.
The Credit She Had Been Paying For Without Knowing It
The Premium Tax Credit is a refundable federal credit designed specifically for people who purchase health insurance through the ACA marketplace and whose household income falls between 100% and 400% of the Federal Poverty Level — though temporary provisions have extended eligibility beyond that cap in recent years. Crucially, it can be claimed either in advance (reducing monthly premiums directly) or as a lump sum when filing taxes.
Rochelle had done neither. She enrolled directly in her plan, paid full sticker price every month, and never applied for advance payments. As a result, she had essentially made an interest-free loan to the federal government for two full years.
When I asked Rochelle why she had never looked into the credit before, her answer was honest and, I suspect, common. “I figured it was for people who really don’t have anything,” she said. “I work. Dennis worked. I didn’t think we were the kind of people who got government help with insurance.” There is no income threshold for that kind of thinking, and it costs families real money every year.
A Mixed Win: The Money She Got Back, and the Years She Cannot
The $3,100 refund is real and it matters. For Rochelle and Dennis, that money represents nearly four months of groceries, or a significant chunk of a car repair she had been deferring on her pickup truck. She was grateful. But as we talked longer, a quieter frustration surfaced.
Rochelle had enrolled in marketplace coverage in 2023 as well — and paid full premiums that year too, without claiming any credit. That filing window is now closed. The IRS generally allows amended returns within three years, but Rochelle had not kept her 2023 Form 1095-A, and the process of reconstructing that year’s return felt daunting. Gary was honest with her: it might be possible to amend, but it would require additional documentation and time she wasn’t sure she had.
“That’s the part that stings,” Rochelle told me. “It’s not like I was careless. I was trying to do everything right, pay my own way. And I still got it wrong because nobody ever explained it to me.” The guilt she directed at herself was palpable — not the guilt of someone who had been irresponsible, but of someone who had tried hard and still ended up behind.
The conversation also surfaced the retirement savings gap, which Gary gently raised. With no employer-sponsored retirement plan and no personal IRA, Rochelle and Dennis have almost nothing set aside beyond Dennis’s small pension. Gary mentioned the Retirement Savings Contributions Credit — sometimes called the Saver’s Credit — which offers a federal tax credit of up to 50% of the first $2,000 contributed to an eligible retirement account, depending on income. At their combined income level, Rochelle would qualify for a 10% credit rate, meaning a $2,000 IRA contribution made before the April 15 deadline could yield a $200 credit for 2025. It is not a solution to a 26-year savings gap, but it is a start.
“I told Gary I felt like I was just finding out the rules of a game I’ve been playing my whole life,” Rochelle said. “You spend all this time working and you don’t even know what you’re entitled to.”
What Rochelle’s Story Reveals About Who Gets Left Behind
Rochelle Mendez is not a hard-luck case in the conventional sense. She earns a consistent income. She has a stable marriage. She made the responsible choice to buy health insurance even when it was painful. And yet the structure of the tax code — built on forms, thresholds, and election windows that most working people have no reason to understand — quietly worked against her for years.
There are roughly 14 million people enrolled in ACA marketplace plans, according to CMS data. A significant portion of those enrollees either underestimate their PTC eligibility or, like Rochelle, simply never engage with the credit at all. Free filing assistance programs — VITA sites, AARP Tax-Aide, and others — exist precisely to close that gap, but they remain underused, often associated in the public mind with poverty rather than complexity.
When I left the community center that afternoon, Rochelle was still at the table with Gary, working through whether her 2024 return could be amended. She had her phone out and was photographing every document Gary referenced. The analytical side of her had fully engaged. The $3,100 refund would be direct-deposited within three weeks. She was already thinking about where it should go.
“I’m not going to feel good about this until I understand every line of that form,” she told me as I gathered my notes. “That’s just how I am. But yeah — $3,100 back feels a lot better than nothing.”
It does. And it should not have taken a folding table in a community center to make it happen.
Vivienne Marlowe Reyes is a Senior Tax & Stimulus Writer at American Relief. She covers federal tax credits, government benefit programs, and economic relief for working families.
Related: A Delivery Driver Walked Into a Medicare Event With the Wrong Questions — and Left With a Lifeline
Related: His $4,200 Tax Refund Was Seized Over a Loan He Cosigned — And He Never Saw It Coming
Leave a Reply