The conventional wisdom says that getting a graduate degree is always worth it. More education, more earning potential — the math is supposed to be simple. But when I sat down with Marcus Dillard in a coffee shop off Peachtree Street in Atlanta on a Tuesday afternoon in late February 2026, he looked like a man who had been lied to by that math for years.
Marcus is 34 years old. He teaches high school algebra and geometry at a public school in DeKalb County. He has two kids — ages five and two — a wife who recently cut her work hours after their second child was born, and $62,000 in federal student loans from a master’s in education he finished in 2018. He told me he hadn’t opened his banking app in three weeks.
“I know roughly what’s in there,” he said, wrapping both hands around a coffee mug. “But looking at it makes it real. And when it’s real, I can’t sleep.”
Growing Up in a House Where Money Was Never Mentioned
Before I could understand where Marcus was financially, I needed to understand where he came from. He grew up in southwest Atlanta, the youngest of three kids. His mother worked as a licensed practical nurse; his father drove for a regional trucking company. They owned their home and paid their bills, but money was never a topic at the dinner table.
“We weren’t broke, but nobody talked about debt, interest rates, any of that,” Marcus told me. “I didn’t know what a credit score was until I was 22. I’m not exaggerating.” That silence, he said, felt normal at the time. It only started to feel like a gap when the bills began stacking up in his late twenties.
When Marcus decided to pursue a master’s degree at a Georgia state university, he took out federal Direct Unsubsidized Loans at an interest rate of 6.54 percent — the standard graduate rate at the time. He assumed the degree would lead to a department head or instructional coach role within a few years. That promotion hasn’t come yet. His current base salary is approximately $54,000 per year before taxes, a figure that puts him in the middle range for DeKalb County teachers with his experience level.
When a Second Child Changed Everything
Marcus’s wife, Tamika, was working full-time as an administrative coordinator at a healthcare management firm when their first child was born in 2020. They managed. Childcare for one ran about $800 a month in their area, and with two incomes — roughly $95,000 combined at the time — they were staying ahead of things, if barely.
Their second child arrived in early 2024. Tamika’s employer did not offer paid parental leave beyond six weeks. After returning to work, the cost of childcare for two children jumped to approximately $1,400 a month. Tamika ran the numbers and realized she was clearing less than $600 per month after childcare costs, commuting expenses, and taxes. She reduced her hours to part-time in September 2024.
“She did the math and it just didn’t make sense anymore,” Marcus said. “But now I’m carrying everything, and the student loans are still there, and the credit cards we put the car repair on last year — it just compounds.” He paused. “I teach compound interest to teenagers. I know exactly how bad it gets. That’s the worst part.”
By January 2026, Marcus and Tamika were carrying approximately $7,200 in credit card debt across two cards, both near their limits. His federal student loan payment under a standard repayment plan was $690 per month. His loan servicer had placed him on a standard 10-year schedule because he had never requested an alternative.
The Programs He Had Never Heard Of
This is where the story shifts — and not in the sweeping, dramatic way Marcus had hoped for. There was no single windfall. What changed was information.
A colleague at his school mentioned the Income-Driven Repayment plans available through Federal Student Aid. Marcus, who had never revisited his repayment options after leaving school, had no idea his monthly payment could potentially be reduced based on his income and family size. Under the SAVE plan — Saving on a Valuable Education — borrowers with federal loans can have their payments capped at a percentage of their discretionary income, as defined by the Department of Education.
Marcus also learned — for the first time, he told me, despite teaching for eight years — that he may qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF). Under that program, federal borrowers who work full-time for a qualifying government or nonprofit employer and make 120 qualifying monthly payments may have their remaining balance forgiven. Public school teachers in Georgia qualify. According to the Federal Student Aid office, borrowers must submit an Employment Certification Form annually to track progress.
The Turning Point: Filing Taxes He Had Been Dreading
When Marcus and Tamika filed their 2025 federal tax return in February 2026, it was the first year they used a paid tax preparer rather than a free online service. The preparer — a CPA at a small firm in Decatur — identified both the Child Tax Credit and the Child and Dependent Care Credit applied to their situation.
Their refund came in at roughly $4,100. That was not a transformational number. It did not erase the credit card debt or the student loans. But Marcus told me it was the first time in four years he and Tamika had a conversation about money that didn’t end in silence or an argument.
He also submitted his PSLF Employment Certification Form for the first time. His loan servicer confirmed that, pending review, he had approximately 96 qualifying payments already credited — meaning he may be fewer than 24 payments away from potential forgiveness on his remaining balance. That number is not guaranteed; PSLF has a historically complex approval process, and the program’s rules have shifted over the years.
What Marcus Still Carries
I want to be honest about where Marcus’s story ends — at least as of late March 2026. His situation is not resolved. His student loans are still there. His credit card balance is still just over $5,000 after that refund payment. Tamika is still working part-time. The financial pressure hasn’t lifted so much as shifted slightly.
What changed, he told me, was the feeling of paralysis. The avoidance. He opened his banking app the morning after we spoke, he texted me later that week. It wasn’t a proud declaration. It was just a thing he did.
That’s the detail that stayed with me after I left the coffee shop. Not the dollar amounts — though those matter — but the information gap. Marcus spent eight years making loan payments on a standard schedule, unaware that his employer category alone might have put him on a path to forgiveness. He filed taxes each year without knowing what credits his household qualified for.
He’s a math teacher. He understands the formulas. He just never had the inputs.
The programs Marcus discovered — PSLF, income-driven repayment, the Child Tax Credit, the Child and Dependent Care Credit — are all documented through the IRS and Federal Student Aid. They were available to him for years. The gap wasn’t the programs. It was the conversation nobody in Marcus’s life ever started.
Related: I Make $72,000 as a Nurse in Denver and Still Applied for SNAP — Here’s What Happened
Leave a Reply