She’s Covered Her Brother’s Disability Costs for 15 Years. What the Government Pays — and What Falls on Her

The filing deadline for the 2025 tax year is April 15, 2026 — and for family caregivers who support disabled relatives, that window represents one…

She's Covered Her Brother's Disability Costs for 15 Years. What the Government Pays — and What Falls on Her
She's Covered Her Brother's Disability Costs for 15 Years. What the Government Pays — and What Falls on Her

The filing deadline for the 2025 tax year is April 15, 2026 — and for family caregivers who support disabled relatives, that window represents one of the few moments each year when some of what they’ve quietly spent can be partially recovered. When I sat down with Monique Washington last month at a diner near her home in Baltimore’s Belair-Edison neighborhood, she had just gotten off a ten-hour shift and was still in her brown UPS uniform. She had a folder of receipts on the table. She’d never brought receipts to a tax appointment before.

Monique is 43 years old. She has driven for UPS for fourteen years, earns roughly $78,000 annually with overtime, and belongs to the Teamsters union. By most measures, she is financially stable. By her own accounting, she is one car repair away from not making rent.

KEY TAKEAWAY
Monique Washington has spent an estimated $15,000 to $17,000 per year out of pocket on her brother’s supplemental care — costs that Medicaid and SSDI combined do not cover. Over 15 years, that adds up to more than $225,000 she has not been able to put toward her own retirement.

A Brother’s Accident, a Family’s Silence, and One Woman Left Holding It All

Monique’s younger brother, Darius, was 25 when a driver ran a red light in 2011 and hit the car he was a passenger in. He sustained a traumatic brain injury and spinal damage that left him with permanent cognitive and mobility limitations. He requires daily assistance with basic tasks. He cannot drive. He cannot hold consistent employment.

Their parents were both alive when the accident happened, and for several years the caregiving was shared. Their mother passed in 2018, their father in 2021. With no other siblings and no extended family nearby, Monique became — in her words — “the plan.”

“Nobody sat me down and said, ‘Monique, this is your life now.’ It just became my life. You don’t get a memo. You just stop doing other things and start doing this.”
— Monique Washington, UPS driver and sole caregiver, Baltimore, MD

Darius currently receives Social Security Disability Insurance. Because his work history was limited at the time of his injury — he’d been working part-time and attending community college — his monthly benefit is approximately $1,090, well below the Social Security Administration’s 2025 average SSDI payment of $1,537. He is also enrolled in Maryland Medicaid, which covers his primary physician visits and a portion of his in-home aide hours.

The portion Medicaid doesn’t cover is where Monique’s budget disappears.

$1,090
Darius’s monthly SSDI benefit

~$1,400
Monique’s estimated monthly out-of-pocket contribution

$0
Retirement contributions in the past 4 years

Where the Money Goes, Line by Line

Monique tracked her expenses for the first time when she prepared for our conversation. She itemized three categories: supplemental in-home care hours beyond what Maryland Medicaid’s Community First Choice waiver covers, accessible transportation for Darius’s medical appointments and therapy sessions, and medical supplies — adaptive equipment, wound care materials, incontinence products — that Medicaid reimburses inconsistently or not at all.

  • Supplemental aide hours: approximately $480/month, covering roughly 30 hours of additional care Medicaid does not authorize
  • Accessible transportation: approximately $260/month for medical transport and non-emergency rides Medicaid’s transportation benefit doesn’t reach
  • Medical supplies and adaptive equipment: approximately $340/month, including a $1,200 wheelchair cushion she purchased last fall after Medicaid denied the claim twice
  • Miscellaneous care-related costs (dietary supplements, home modifications, over-the-counter medications): approximately $180/month

That total — roughly $1,260 to $1,400 per month — comes directly from Monique’s paycheck. Over the course of a year, it approaches $17,000. She hasn’t made a contribution to her Teamsters pension supplement in four years. She cashed out a small 401(k) in 2022 to cover a plumbing emergency and a broken hospital bed motor in the same month.

⚠ IMPORTANT
Cashing out a retirement account before age 59½ typically triggers a 10% early withdrawal penalty plus ordinary income tax on the amount withdrawn. For caregivers in financial distress, this creates a compounding loss — both the retirement savings and a portion of the withdrawal itself are gone. Monique says she paid approximately $1,800 in penalties and taxes on that withdrawal.

The Tax Appointment That Changed One Number — Not the Whole Picture

For years, Monique filed her taxes the same way: standard deduction, single filer, done in under an hour. She didn’t think she qualified for anything special. When her coworker mentioned a tax preparer in Towson who specialized in caregiving situations, Monique made an appointment mostly out of curiosity.

What the preparer found shifted her refund significantly — though not enough to resolve the larger problem. Because Monique provides more than half of Darius’s financial support and he meets the IRS’s qualifying relative definition, she was eligible to file as Head of Household and claim the Credit for Other Dependents, worth $500. More importantly, the preparer identified that Monique’s unreimbursed medical expenses paid on Darius’s behalf — totaling approximately $8,400 for 2024 — exceeded the 7.5% of adjusted gross income threshold required to itemize medical deductions under IRS Publication 502.

How the Medical Expense Deduction Worked in Monique’s Case
1
Calculate 7.5% of AGI — With $78,000 in gross income, the threshold was $5,850. Only medical expenses above that amount are deductible.

2
Total qualifying medical expenses — Monique documented approximately $8,400 in unreimbursed medical costs paid for Darius in 2024.

3
Deductible amount — $8,400 minus $5,850 equals $2,550 in deductible medical expenses, reducing her taxable income when itemizing.

4
Combined effect with Head of Household and dependent credit — Her total refund increased by approximately $1,100 compared to prior years.

She also learned about ABLE accounts — tax-advantaged savings accounts for people with disabilities that don’t count against SSI or Medicaid eligibility asset limits. Darius could theoretically hold up to $100,000 in an ABLE account without jeopardizing his benefits. Monique had never heard of them.

“She told me about the ABLE account and I literally sat there like — this exists? For fifteen years this has existed and nobody told me? I cried in her office. Not because it fixes everything. It doesn’t. But because somebody finally looked at my situation like it was a real situation.”
— Monique Washington

What the Numbers Recovered — and What They Couldn’t

The 2024 tax filing ultimately returned Monique approximately $2,800 more than she would have received under her previous approach. It was the largest refund she had seen in a decade. She used $1,400 to pay down a medical credit card she’d opened in 2023 to cover Darius’s adaptive shower chair and grab bar installation. The remaining $1,400 went into a small emergency fund she is trying to rebuild.

She did not put anything toward retirement. She is 43 years old and has, by her own estimate, less than $12,000 in any retirement account.

KEY TAKEAWAY
Monique’s 2024 tax filing — her first with a caregiver-specialist preparer — returned approximately $1,100 more than her standard approach would have. The Credit for Other Dependents ($500), Head of Household filing status, and itemized medical deductions all contributed. But the structural shortfall in her brother’s disability coverage remains unchanged.

When I asked Monique whether she resented the position she found herself in, she went quiet for a moment. She picked up her coffee cup, set it back down without drinking from it.

“I don’t resent Darius. I want to be clear about that. But I do resent that the system is designed for somebody else to be helping him. And that somebody just happened to be me because there was nobody left. I didn’t choose this the way people choose things. I just didn’t leave.”
— Monique Washington

She told me she hasn’t taken a real vacation since 2019, when she and a friend drove to Virginia Beach for three days and she spent most of it on the phone arranging Darius’s temporary care coverage. She said she’s not looking for sympathy. She’s looking for a system that doesn’t require her to choose between his present and her future.

The Larger Gap No Tax Credit Closes

Monique’s situation reflects a structural reality in how disability benefits are designed in the United States. SSDI payments are calculated based on a recipient’s lifetime earnings record — meaning younger people who acquire disabilities before accumulating significant work history receive lower benefits, often far below what independent living actually costs.

Care Cost Category What Medicaid/SSDI Covers What Monique Covers
In-home aide hours Partial (Medicaid waiver authorized hours) ~$480/month supplemental
Medical transportation Limited Medicaid transport benefit ~$260/month gap
Medical supplies & equipment Inconsistent; frequent denials ~$340/month
Miscellaneous care costs Not covered ~$180/month
Total monthly gap ~$1,260–$1,400

Monique told me she plans to file on time this April, using the same preparer from Towson. She’s already collected twelve months of receipts in a folder — the same one she brought to our meeting. She is hoping the deductible medical expenses will again exceed the 7.5% threshold. She is not counting on it.

“I keep the receipts now. That’s the thing I changed. I keep every single receipt. It’s not going to change Darius’s situation. But at least I stopped leaving money on the table that I actually earned.”
— Monique Washington

When I left the diner, Monique was already on her phone — not scrolling, but on a call, her voice dropping to the low, patient register of someone explaining a medication schedule to a home aide. She waved goodbye with one hand without looking up. She had another shift starting at 5 a.m.

The folder of receipts sat on the table until she scooped it up on her way out. She’s keeping it this time.

Related: Claiming Social Security at 62 Feels Smart Until You See What It Actually Costs You Over 20 Years

Related: I Watched My Tax Refund Stay ‘Approved’ for 31 Days — What the IRS Status Screen Isn’t Telling You

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a family caregiver claim a disabled sibling as a dependent on their taxes?

Yes, under IRS qualifying relative rules, a sibling can be claimed as a dependent if the taxpayer provides more than 50% of their financial support and the sibling’s gross income falls below the IRS threshold (which was $5,050 for 2024). This may also enable Head of Household filing status, which carries a more favorable tax rate.
What is the Credit for Other Dependents and how much is it worth?

The Credit for Other Dependents is a nonrefundable federal tax credit worth up to $500 for each qualifying dependent who does not meet the criteria for the Child Tax Credit — including disabled adult relatives. It was introduced under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 and remains in effect for tax year 2025.
Do unreimbursed medical expenses paid for a disabled family member qualify for the IRS medical deduction?

Yes. According to IRS Publication 502, medical expenses paid on behalf of a qualifying dependent — including a sibling you claim as a dependent — are deductible to the extent they exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income, provided you itemize deductions.
What is an ABLE account and does it affect Medicaid or SSI eligibility?

An ABLE account (Achieving a Better Life Experience) is a tax-advantaged savings account for people with disabilities established before age 46. Per the Social Security Administration, the first $100,000 in an ABLE account does not count toward the SSI asset limit of $2,000. Funds can be used for qualified disability expenses including housing, transportation, medical care, and personal support services.
What is the typical SSDI monthly payment for someone who became disabled at age 25?

SSDI payments are based on a recipient’s lifetime average indexed monthly earnings. Someone who became disabled at 25 with limited work history typically receives well below the national average. The Social Security Administration reported the average SSDI payment for 2025 was approximately $1,537 per month, but workers with short earnings records often receive between $800 and $1,200.

467 articles

Vivienne Marlowe Reyes

Senior Tax & Stimulus Writer covering stimulus payments, tax credits, and IRS policy. M.S. Tax Policy Georgetown. Former U.S. Treasury analyst. Enrolled Agent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *