Roughly 2.2 million Americans are enrolled in COBRA continuation coverage at any given time, according to estimates from the U.S. Department of Labor. Most of them are paying full freight — the employee’s share, the employer’s share, and a 2% administrative fee — with no subsidy and no ceiling. For Travis Underwood, that number worked out to $847 every single month. His rent in Tucson was $780.
I met Travis through a mutual friend, Elena Castillo, at a backyard barbecue in the Barrio Historico neighborhood last October. Elena had mentioned, half-laughing over a plate of carne asada, that her friend the math teacher was “drowning in paperwork and premiums.” She thought I might want to hear his story. Travis agreed to sit down with me the following Saturday, then again two weeks later when the first conversation ran long.
He is 31 years old, trim, with the kind of measured calm you sometimes find in people who spend their days managing twenty-five teenagers at once. But when the subject turned to his bank account, something tightened in his expression. “I just stopped looking at my statements for a while,” he told me, straightening a coffee mug that didn’t need straightening. “Which I know is the worst thing you can do. But when every number is bad, you just stop opening the app.”
How a Single Insurance Claim Set Off a Chain Reaction
Travis had been teaching at a public high school in the Sunnyside Unified School District since 2019. For the first few years, his district’s health plan covered him without incident. The problems started in the spring of 2024, when a monsoon-season storm peeled back a section of the roof on his rented casita and sent water into the living room. He filed a claim with his renters’ and property insurer — a regional carrier he’d been with for four years — expecting a routine payout.
The claim was paid, eventually. The policy was not renewed. “They sent me a letter in August,” Travis told me, “saying they were ‘non-renewing’ my coverage effective September 15th. I had to look up what that even meant.” What it meant, in practice, was that he had roughly six weeks to find new property coverage — in an Arizona insurance market that was quietly tightening after years of wildfire and storm losses across the Southwest.
The property insurance problem was stressful but ultimately solvable — he found a new carrier at roughly $180 a month, about $60 more than his previous premium. The health insurance situation was different in kind, not just degree.
In January 2025, Travis left the district mid-year to deal with a family situation in Phoenix — his younger sister, Marisol, was struggling in her second semester at Arizona State, and he wanted to be closer for a few months while she stabilized. He resigned, which triggered the end of his employer coverage, which triggered COBRA. He returned to Tucson and was rehired by the same district in August 2025, but that gap — roughly seven months — cost him dearly.
The Weight of Supporting Someone Else While Drowning Yourself
Travis is the oldest of three siblings. His parents are in Nogales and send what they can, but Marisol’s tuition, books, and living costs at ASU fell largely on him. “She’s going to graduate,” he said, with a firmness that made it clear this was not negotiable. “I didn’t have anyone helping me through school. She’s not going to be in that position.”
The transfers to Marisol averaged $400 a month through the gap period, sometimes spiking to $600 when a textbook bill or a car repair showed up. Combined with the $847 COBRA premium, Travis was spending more than $1,200 a month before rent, food, utilities, or the new property insurance premium. His savings, which had been about $8,400 in January 2025, had fallen to roughly $2,100 by May.
Travis is not low-income by most federal definitions. His teacher’s salary, before he resigned, was approximately $52,000 annually. That put him above the poverty line but below the threshold where COBRA feels affordable — especially without an employer contributing to the premium. This is a gap that policy researchers have noted for years: moderate-income workers between jobs often earn too much to qualify for Medicaid but too little to absorb full COBRA costs without erosion of savings.
The Turning Point: A Form He Almost Threw Away
In March 2025, Travis received a letter from Healthcare.gov confirming a Special Enrollment Period triggered by his loss of employer coverage. He had received a similar notice in January and ignored it, assuming — incorrectly — that his income level made him ineligible for subsidized marketplace coverage. “I thought marketplace plans were for people who couldn’t afford anything,” he told me. “I didn’t think I qualified.”
A colleague at the school where he’d done some substitute teaching mentioned the Advance Premium Tax Credit, which was expanded under the American Rescue Plan and then extended through 2025 under the Inflation Reduction Act. Under those provisions, households earning up to 400% of the federal poverty level — and in some cases above — could receive premium subsidies on marketplace plans. For a single individual in 2025, 400% of the FPL was approximately $60,240.
Travis’s projected annual income during the gap period — pieced together from substitute teaching and some tutoring work — was approximately $31,000. That put him solidly within the range for a meaningful subsidy. When he finally logged on to Healthcare.gov and ran the numbers, the credit reduced his premium from $847 to $214 a month for a comparable Silver-tier plan.
What the Numbers Actually Looked Like at the End
The three months Travis spent on COBRA before switching — January through March 2025 — cost him $2,541 in premiums he could have avoided, or significantly reduced, had he acted on the first enrollment notice. He is candid about this. “That’s on me,” he said. “I assumed I didn’t qualify and I didn’t check. That assumption cost me two and a half grand.”
By the time Travis was rehired in August 2025, he had rebuilt his savings to approximately $4,600 — still below where he started, but no longer in crisis territory. Marisol is on track to graduate from ASU in December 2026. Travis says the monthly transfers have tapered slightly, to around $300, now that she has a part-time campus job.
When I asked Travis what he would tell someone in a similar situation today, he paused for a long moment before answering. “Just go look. Go to the actual government websites. Don’t assume. The assumption cost me more than I want to think about.” He laughed a little at that — the laugh of someone who has earned the right to find something both painful and instructive.
There is no triumphant ending here, exactly. Travis still carries the memory of watching his savings drop by more than $6,000 in five months, still feels the weight of being someone’s safety net while building his own. But he is enrolled in his district’s health plan again, his sister is finishing her degree, and he has started opening his banking app on a regular schedule — Sunday mornings, he told me, before he makes coffee.
“Small victories,” he said. “You celebrate the small ones when the big ones aren’t available.”
Vivienne Marlowe Reyes is a Senior Tax & Stimulus Writer at American Relief. She covers economic relief programs, government benefits, and the financial lives of working Americans.
Related: A Firefighter’s COBRA Bill Hit $1,847 a Month — More Than His Rent — After a Friend’s Loan Default
Leave a Reply