The Social Security Administration announced a 2.5 percent cost-of-living adjustment for 2026 — the smallest increase in five years — at the same moment that Medicare Part D out-of-pocket costs were climbing faster than that for many beneficiaries on fixed incomes. For retirees who planned their finances expecting those two numbers to roughly track each other, the gap is quietly devastating.
I met Roy Bianchi on a Tuesday afternoon in February 2026, at a CVS pharmacy off South Tryon Street in Charlotte, North Carolina. He was at the pharmacy counter, speaking in a low voice to the technician, asking whether any programs existed to help with the cost of two medications he had just been prescribed. He wasn’t angry. He wasn’t raising his voice. He looked like a man doing mental math and not liking what it came to.
I introduced myself after he stepped away from the window. Roy — six feet tall, broad-shouldered, with the quiet bearing of someone who has spent decades lifting, hauling, and navigating routes in all weather — was polite but guarded at first. When I mentioned I covered economic relief programs, he paused, then said: “I didn’t think I’d be standing here trying to figure out how to pay for pills at sixty-six.”
We sat down a few days later at a diner near his home in Charlotte’s Steele Creek neighborhood. Over two hours, Roy Bianchi told me the kind of story that doesn’t make headlines — because it isn’t a crisis. It’s a slow, grinding monthly shortfall that he handles alone, without asking anyone for help.
Thirty-Two Years on the Road, and a Retirement That Doesn’t Quite Add Up
Roy Bianchi retired from UPS in January 2025 after 32 years as a package car driver. He was 65. He had planned for this date carefully, or believed he had. Between a Social Security retirement benefit of $2,840 per month and a Teamsters pension check of $1,190 per month, Roy brings in roughly $4,030 per month in retirement income.
His monthly expenses, which he laid out for me on a folded piece of paper he had brought to the diner, run closer to $4,650. Mortgage: $1,210. Utilities, groceries, and transportation: roughly $1,100. Medicare Part B premiums plus a supplemental Medigap policy: $487. Prescriptions: $210, though that number had just climbed when one of his medications lost its generic status. And then there was the student loan payment: $387 per month on a remaining $47,000 balance from an MBA he completed at 54, hoping it would open a path into UPS management. That path never materialized.
The $620 monthly gap comes out of a 401(k) he built across three decades of driving, currently sitting at approximately $338,000. Roy knows the arithmetic. At that withdrawal rate, factoring in any market volatility and unplanned medical costs, that account has a finite runway. “I do the numbers every few months,” he told me, turning his coffee cup slowly on the table. “I try not to do them more than that, because the answer doesn’t change.”
The Disability Piece That Complicated Everything
What separates Roy’s situation from a standard retirement budget shortfall is a back injury he sustained in 2019, during his final years on route. A herniated disc at L4-L5, the cumulative result of decades loading and unloading packages in awkward positions, left him with chronic pain requiring ongoing physical therapy and twice-yearly steroid injections. He manages it. Managing it costs money his benefits weren’t built to absorb.
Roy was approved for Social Security Disability Insurance in 2021, then converted to standard retirement benefits at 65. What he underestimated was how much of his actual medical cost the transition to Medicare would leave exposed. His Medigap policy covers most hospital and physician costs, but it doesn’t reach the physical therapy copays, the injection appointments, or the prescription line items that had started climbing.
“When I was still driving, I figured Medicare was Medicare,” Roy told me. “I didn’t know there were all these different layers and gaps. Nobody sat me down and explained it. I figured it out as the bills came in.”
The Pharmacy Counter — and What Roy Didn’t Know He Was Missing
The afternoon I encountered Roy at CVS, he was asking specifically about Medicare Extra Help — a program he had only just heard about from a neighbor who had gotten it for her mother. Roy had been paying his full Part D cost-sharing on two medications for over a year, with no knowledge that a subsidy might exist.
Roy’s combined income — approximately $48,360 per year between Social Security and his Teamsters pension — places him above the threshold for either tier of Extra Help. The full subsidy in 2026 requires individual income below roughly $19,683 (135 percent of the federal poverty level). The partial subsidy extends to approximately $21,870 (150 percent FPL). At nearly $48,000 in annual income, Roy doesn’t qualify for either. His income is too high for most federal prescription assistance programs, and too low for his expenses not to matter.
Standing at the pharmacy counter and learning he didn’t qualify, Roy said, was a specific kind of deflating. “The lady was very nice about it. She said I might check whether the drug companies had their own programs. But I hadn’t planned for any of this. I thought I’d covered my bases over thirty years.”
The Student Loan That Followed Him Into Retirement
The $47,000 in federal student loan debt is the detail of Roy’s story that surprised me most when he mentioned it. He earned his MBA from a regional university in 2014, attending evening classes three nights a week while still working his full UPS route. His goal was a move into logistics management — something a little easier on his back, a little more stable as he aged into his late 50s. UPS reorganized its management pipeline around that time, and Roy, by then in his mid-50s, found the door effectively closed.
He has been on a standard 10-year repayment plan since the loans came due. With $387 per month in payments and interest that consumed most of his early principal reductions, he entered retirement carrying debt he had fully expected to be clear of by now. The loan is the single largest adjustable line item in his monthly budget — and it hasn’t moved much.
Federal student loan borrowers — including retirees — may apply for income-driven repayment plans through Federal Student Aid, which can recalculate a monthly payment based on discretionary income rather than loan balance. The SAVE plan, one available IDR option, is currently subject to ongoing legal challenges as of early 2026, and its status remains unresolved. Roy had not yet called his loan servicer to explore any of these options when we spoke.
What Roy Had Done — and What He Hadn’t
In the three weeks between our pharmacy encounter and our diner meeting, Roy had made some targeted progress. He contacted both drug manufacturers directly, as the pharmacist had suggested. One enrollment in a patient assistance program reduced his out-of-pocket cost on one medication from $94 per month to $25 — a $69 monthly saving. The second medication had no equivalent program. Net result: a partial fix that helped, without solving the underlying equation.
Roy’s savings withdrawal trajectory, assuming modest average market returns and no significant unplanned medical event, projects his 401(k) sustaining withdrawals at that rate for roughly 22 to 25 years — potentially into his late 80s. He does not find that projection reassuring. “I know what can go wrong,” he said, his voice matter-of-fact. “I watched my wife go through a long illness before she passed. I know exactly what that costs, even with good insurance.”
Roy’s wife, Diane, died in 2020 after a two-year illness. He mentioned it once and didn’t return to it. But it was clear that her illness — and the financial weight of it — had permanently altered how he thinks about the relationship between savings and security. A number that looks sufficient on a spreadsheet is not the same thing as feeling safe.
A Story About Gaps Nobody Designed and Dignity Nobody Should Have to Negotiate
Driving back from Steele Creek that evening, I kept returning to the space between what the benefit system was built to do and what Roy Bianchi actually needs it to do. His income isn’t low enough to qualify for most means-tested programs. It isn’t high enough to absorb the real costs of retirement with a chronic disability, climbing prescription expenses, and a student loan balance that followed him out the door.
He sits in a bracket the safety net wasn’t really designed for: the working retiree who did most things right — worked for decades, saved consistently, earned a pension through a union — and still finds himself $620 short every month, slowly spending down an account he spent 32 years building and hoped he wouldn’t have to touch for a long time yet.
The programs Roy might still pursue — state pharmaceutical assistance through North Carolina’s Division of Aging and Adult Services, a loan servicer conversation about IDR recalculation, a review of whether any Medicare Savings Program tier might apply to reduce Part B premiums — represent real, available options. Whether any of them materially move the needle on his monthly numbers remains an open question.
When I asked Roy what he would tell someone in a similar position — someone who had worked hard, planned carefully, and still come up a few hundred dollars short every month — he was quiet for a moment before answering. “Don’t wait as long as I did to start asking questions,” he said. “That’s it. That’s the only thing I’d say. Ask sooner.”
It wasn’t advice. It was just the thing he wished he had known.
Leave a Reply